Finger Lakes Property Rentals - Vacation Rentals in Hay Beach

'The Gate House'on Beach front Estate with Dockage. Walk to Village . From US $703
         

Quaint DT Greenport Apt - 2 Mi to Shelter Island! From US $208
         

|
10.0 (3 Reviews)
Apartment
  • Parking
  • View
  • Balcony/Terrace
Stirling House Bed & Breakfast From US $383
         

|
9.8 (25 Reviews)
Bed & Breakfast
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • TV
Cottage on Beach front Estate with Dockage .Walk to Village From US $643
         

9.8 (84 Reviews)
Cottage
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
1820 Whaling Captain's Home - A walk to a coffee or cocktail! From US $851
         

10.0 (56 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Relaxing Private Retreat Near Preserve. Pets Welcome! From US $582
         

10.0 (53 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Pet Friendly
  • Security/Safety

Luxury Places to Stay in Hay Beach

Over 437+ Luxury Places to Stay in or Near Hay Beach
Shelter Island House From US $2,700
         

|
8.7 (7 Reviews)
Hotel
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Relax and Enjoy! From US $2,611
         

10.0 (16 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Casa Greenport From US $2,587
         

New
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly

Top-Rated Vacation Rentals with a Pool in Hay Beach

Over 143+ Top-Rated Vacation Rentals with a Pool in or Near Hay Beach
Bohemian Old Life Saving Station with Beach & Pool From US $1,682
         

10.0 (33 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
House by the Bay with Large In-ground Pool, Steps from Beach From US $750
         

10.0 (27 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Lovely home by the sea with dock and heated Gunite pool! From US $656
         

Pet-Friendly Vacation Rentals in Hay Beach

Over 160+ Pet-Friendly Vacation Rentals in or Near Hay Beach
Brand new 2 bedroom, Greenport Village, walk to town Marina Views! From US $724
         

Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach From US $341
         

|
9.9 (93 Reviews)
Bed & Breakfast
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
North Fork Resort From US $312
         

|
9.2 (20 Reviews)
Cottage
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Cleves Point Estates Home, Private sandy beach From US $475
         

10.0 (26 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Blue Bay Dream w/Seasonal Outdoor Jacuzzi, Cabana + Office From US $443
         

10.0 (25 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Huge Island Getaway Pool Hot Tub Walk To Beach From US $1,950
         

10.0 (7 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly

Large Vacation Homes & Villas in Hay Beach

Over 70+ Large Vacation Homes & Villas in or Near Hay Beach
House on Chase Creek From US $367
         

|
9.2 (15 Reviews)
Bed & Breakfast
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • View
Bright and Spacious Summer Home Steps from the Beach From US $812
         

Wheelchair Accessible Vacation Homes in Hay Beach

Over 20+ Wheelchair Accessible Vacation Homes in or Near Hay Beach
American Beech in Greenport - Deluxe King 6 From US $368
         

2.0 (1 Review)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Pet Friendly
  • TV
The Cliffside Resort Condominiums From US $405
         

|
9.0 (249 Reviews)
Apartment
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pool
The Menhaden From US $440
         

|
9.6 (179 Reviews)
Hotel
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pool
American Beech in Greenport - King Suite 3 From US $343
         

New
Hotel
  • Air Conditioner
  • TV
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Restored Seaport Home From US $550
         

New
Cottage
  • Air Conditioner
  • TV
  • Wheelchair Accessible

Hay Beach Vacation Rentals and Airbnb Places to Stay Under $200

Over 5+ Hay Beach Vacation Rentals and Airbnb Places to Stay Under $200
Harbor Heights From US $171
         

9.8 (14 Reviews)
Apartment
  • Air Conditioner
  • Pet Friendly
  • Security/Safety
Charming Greenport Gem 1, 1 Mile to Ferry! From US $118
         

|
9.8 (6 Reviews)
Apartment
  • Parking
  • Security/Safety
  • Sports/Activities
Oyster Estate From US $173
         

9.2 (284 Reviews)
Hotel
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pool
Greenport One Bedroom Pied A Terre From US $135
         

4.0 (1 Review)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Bedding/Linens
  • Internet

Instantly Bookable Vacation Homes in Hay Beach

Over 121+ Instantly Bookable Vacation Homes in or Near Hay Beach
Charming Greenport Gem 1, 1 Mile to Ferry! From US $415
         

10.0 (28 Reviews)
Apartment
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • TV
Relaxation in Greenport From US $828
         

10.0 (12 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • TV
Cozy Greenport village cottage From US $1,242
         

10.0 (8 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • TV
Northfork Townhouse walk to all From US $609
         

10.0 (5 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Designated Smoking Area

About Hay Beach Vacation Rentals

With more than 446 Hay Beach vacation rentals, we can help you find a place to stay. These rentals, including vacation rentals, Fingerlakespropertyrentals and other short-term private accommodations, have top-notch amenities with the best value, providing you with comfort and luxury at the same time. Get more value and more room when you stay at a rental property in Hay Beach.

Looking for last-minute deals, or finding the best deals available for cottages, condos, private villas, and large vacation homes? With Fingerlakespropertyrentals Hay Beach, you have the flexibility of comparing different options of various deals with a single click. Looking for a rental by owner with the best swimming pools, hot tubs, allows pets, or even those with huge master suite bedrooms and have large screen televisions? You can find vacation rentals by owner, and other popular Airbnb-style properties in Hay Beach. Places to stay near Hay Beach are 1036.77 ft² on average, with prices averaging US $833 a night.

Fingerlakespropertyrentals makes it easy and safe to find and compare vacation rentals in Hay Beach with prices often at a 30-40% discount versus the price of a hotel. Just search for your destination and secure your reservation today.

Top Rental Accommodation Types in Hay Beach

Type Count
Vacation Homes 319
Cottages 33
Holiday Apartments 30
Hotels 27
Others 12
B&B 10
Villas 3
Cabin Rentals 1
Hostels 1

Use these Quick Filters to Find a Vacation Rental in Hay Beach

Pro Tip: Fingerlakespropertyrentals makes it easy to compare the best listings on Fingerlakespropertyrentals homes from online vacation rental OTAs, including Booking.com and more. Use the Advanced Filter feature at the top to easily flip between Fingerlakespropertyrentals homes, vacation rentals, bed and breakfasts, private Airbnb-style rentals availability, eco-friendly properties, property type, cancellation policies, prices, and several different options. All these make it easier to find the perfect accommodation for your next vacation in Hay Beach.

Weather in Hay Beach

View the weather forecast for Hay Beach before booking your Hay Beach Vacation Rentals to confirm your best time to go.

December - February
High 60°F       Low 26°F
March - May
High 77°F       Low 40°F
June - August
High 91°F       Low 64°F
September - November
High 84°F       Low 38°F

Hay Beach Vacation Rental Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top vacation rentals in Hay Beach?
How many vacation rentals are available in Hay Beach?

Currently, the total number of properties listed in 2026 is over 446 in the Hay Beach area, and still counting. By aggregating listings from multiple websites, offers an immense amount of choice of the best properties in Hay Beach.